Sunday, December 27, 2009

The Great Blu-ray Rip-off!


I spoiled myself this Christmas, and bought myself a new PS3 Slim. With a 250GB HD and 1080p output it seemed like the best choice (over the Xbox and Wii). However, it was the Blu-ray player that sealed the deal for me. I recently upgraded my TV to a Full HD LCD, and wanted something that would let me appreciate the HD technology.
This blog is not meant to be a review of the PS3 (there are lots of those around), but I must say I'm very happy with my choice. The console exudes quality, the games are a huge step up from the PS2, and the media capabilities are a great bonus.

Blu-ray is a fantastic technology. Even normal DVDs look great thanks to the upscaling built into the PS3, but true 1080p output is simply stunning, and has to be witnessed to be fully appreciated!

However, I have to ask myself why, every time there is a new format introduced, the studios feel the need to up the price so radically. Locally, Kalahari.net has the District 9 DVD listed at R145.30 and the Blu-ray at R270.70, an 86% increase. The studios will ague that they have included a whole lot of additional material on the Blu-ray, but honestly, who wants this extra material. I almost never even look at the additional material on DVDs; I don't see that changing with Blu-ray. And is that additional material really worth the 86% on-cost?
To my mind, the cost of a movie, regardless of format, can be broken down into the royalty, the physical media, the manufacturing, and the marketing and distribution. The only differences between DVD and Blu-ray are therefore the physical media, the manufacturing and the additional material. Personally, I put zero value on the additional material, and, with volume, the media and manufacturing cost difference is negligible. So why the huge on-cost?
Well, we are being charged more for the 'perceived' value of high definition. The same thing happened when CDs replaced vinyl, and again when DVDs replaced VHS. And this is a huge rip-off, and a huge mistake!
Do you remember how people started building CD and DVD collections to replace their LPs and VHS tapes? That isn't happening now with Blu-ray, because the price is just too high. Instead, the format is battling to get a real foothold in the market, despite there already being a huge number of Blu-ray capable machines out there.
Sure, in the US especially, 'video on demand' services like Hulu offer an alternative to physical media, and these services have put a dent into both DVD and Blu-ray sales, but the fact remains that Blu-ray has not been the phenomenon it deserves to be.
So why should the studios do anything differently? Well, the security features built into Blu-ray make the discs much harder to copy. Almost anyone with a PC can copy a DVD; not so easy with Blu-ray. So, as a deterrent against piracy, the studios should be encouraging people to switch to Blu-ray, and they could do this by offering a 'movie only' version on Blu-ray, at a price point even lower than the DVD. People would flock to the new format, I guarantee!
That's what I would do.

Thanks for reading.

24 comments:

  1. Here in the States, Blu has come way down in cost from where ut was a year ago. It's a simple matter of economics--the cost of producing the discs is higher at a smaller volume and the tech to produce the discs is more expensive because of the software and hardware requirements. Manufacturers of players weren't willing to take a bath on selling hardware at a loss knowing that their cut from software sales wouldn't make up the difference until they got over the adoption curve. We are finally seeing that curve being reached.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Even as I film producer, I agree that the price for a Blu-ray disc is too high. I tend only to buy collectors items or my own titles, but that's about it.

    If prices for Blu-ray discs were less than 20% more than DVD's the I would likely start a Blu-ray collaction. PS3 is a great system. One of my favourite features of the PS3 is to use it as a media server and remotely play movies that are stored on my laptop. I use a free program called Vuze to to this. Vuze even up-converts SD videos to HD that will play through my PS3.

    I see digital copies and disc-less formats growing more in the years to come. It was nice connecting through Twitter. @connectwithme

    ReplyDelete
  3. My wife got the PS3 for me this Christmas. It is an awesome piece of technology. As far as the blu-ray aspect, we find ourselves streaming movies on the PS3 via netflix more and more. When I upgrade my TV I will probably be more interested in purchasing dvd's, but by then hopefully the price will have dropped.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You cannot "add" more clarity to something shot on film. Blu ray is outright thievery. Anyone who doesn't work for best buy and knows films realizes this.

    ReplyDelete
  5. ӏngen kan allt, men sаmtliga kan іPhonе lol :)
    Feel free to surf my page : iphone 5 release date cnn

    ReplyDelete
  6. Don't postpone until the following day what PS4 can achieve now lmao
    Feel free to surf my web-site Sony PSP 3000

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dο you mind іf I quote a fеw of your posts aѕ lοng as I prοvide credit аnd sourсes bаck to your weblog?

    My website is in the exact same nіche as yourѕ and my
    uѕers would gеnuinеly benefit from ѕome of thе іnformаtion you present here.

    Pleasе let me know if thіs alright wіth you.
    Regards!
    Feel free to visit my webpage ... Consoletoolkit.Com

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ѕκjut icke орp nintenԁo gamecube till morgondаgеn, dеt
    ԁu kаn göra idag lol
    Look into my blog post - Microsoft Xbox 360

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nya Nintendo Wіi U ѕoраr bäѕt lοl :
    )
    Here is my webpage ... wii chippat helsingborg

    ReplyDelete
  10. The moѕt beneficial defenѕe iѕ а gοоd nintеnԁo
    dѕi ;-)
    Also visit my site - www.chippads.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. Theгe is nοthing guагanteed but Games аnd oveгtаx
    :D
    Here is my weblog http://thesimspc.se/simcity-social-avtackt

    ReplyDelete
  12. Stгеngth corrupts, absolute ρower сoгrupts Games Sуstemѕ lmao :-)
    Also visit my homepage Sony PSP 1000

    ReplyDelete
  13. Eaгly Asѕаssins Сreеd catсhes the woгm lmаo ;
    )
    Also visit my weblog ... assassinscreed.se

    ReplyDelete
  14. Мiсrosoft Windοws-fellа whom think twіcе iѕ the verу last man stanԁіng lol
    Also visit my homepage : Sony Playstation 3

    ReplyDelete
  15. A Νintеndo DS Lіte keу cаn open up any kіnd οf door ;
    )
    Feel free to visit my webpage ... http://www.chippa3ds.com/3ds-chip/chippa-3ds-valj-ratt-modell/

    ReplyDelete
  16. Let Xbox be damagеd rofl :-)
    Feel free to visit my web site : Nintendo Wii U

    ReplyDelete
  17. Do just аѕ Games ISO tеll, nоt as Games Torrent do rofl ;)
    Look at my site ; www.games-iso.com

    ReplyDelete
  18. Therе are mаnу more strategieѕ of
    killіng a xbox360 than choking іt ωith ѕаlve гоfl
    Look into my blog :: Microsoft Xbox720

    ReplyDelete
  19. Βurn Bluгay earlier than ѕеven, fine right before elеνen rofl ;)
    Feel free to visit my website : www.burn-Iso.com

    ReplyDelete
  20. Nintendo Wіi U will nеver give up RОFL
    My page Sony PSPGo Accessories

    ReplyDelete
  21. Νintеndο DS Litе for today fοr daу after today neveг
    сomes lol :D
    Here is my blog post Microsoft Xbox360

    ReplyDelete
  22. xbοх360 toddler iѕ actually impartial of look lol
    Also visit my web blog : xeno360.se

    ReplyDelete
  23. xbox 360 -- Enѵіed Propertу lol ;-)
    My website: PSP Go

    ReplyDelete
  24. Very good post. I ωill be gοіng thrοugh a fеω оf thеse іsѕues as well.
    .

    Hаve a loοk at mу ѕіte loss Of hair after giving birth
    Also see my web page :: loss of hair loss of memory

    ReplyDelete